Voters vote 'No' on Manchester congestion fare

At noon today at the Manchester Central conference centre, returning officer Sir Neil McIntosh announced that the majority of voters had voted against the introduction of the congestion charge. Across the 10 regions of Greater Manchester, 1.94 million ballot packs have been sent out over the last 2 weeks. By 10pm last night 1,030,000 residents (53.2% of the electorate) turned out to vote. The scheme needed at least 7 boroughs to vote in favour of the scheme for it go-ahead, but as the following breakdown suggests (see the Middleton Guardian), this didn’t happen:

Borough	Yes Vote	No Vote	Rejected	Overall Outcome	Majority
Manchester	43,593	113,064	250	NO	69,471
Rochdale	17,333	61,686	118	NO	44,353
Bolton	20,529	76,910	167	NO	56,381
Bury	16,563	64,001	94	NO	47,438
Oldham	17,571	68,884	141	NO	51,313
Salford	14,603	79,326	105	NO	64,723
Stockport	24,090	103,706	169	NO	79,616
Tameside	16,323	83,105	124	NO	66,782
Trafford	20,445	83,568	142	NO	63,123
Wigan	27,810	78,565	132	NO	50,755
TOTAL	218,860	812,815	1,442	NO	593,955

The Times suggests that voters were not persuaded by the £1.5 billion Government funding for public transport, despite the fact that it would have created 10,000 extra jobs due to the construction of new tram lines and improved trains and buses. Many questioned the timing of the referendum, which would have seen drivers paying £5 a day (up to £1,200 a year) to get in and out of Manchester (here is a map of the proposed outer and inner rings), due to the current economic climate and the belief that building more roads is not financially possible or environmentally acceptable.

It appears that the vote was decided by whether you drove into Manchester, or took public transport into Manchester. Those who take public transport are more likely to vote in favour of additional public transport, as it would be more beneficial to them and across a year they wouldn’t pay as much as drivers. However, those who drive into Manchester would vote against it, as they would inevitably have to pay up to £5 a day just to go to work, a possible £1,200 a year, which for someone with a basic salary could be quite a financial burden. Similarly, those travelling from the most furthest out boroughs in Greater Manchester would prefer to drive over public transport, as it is a lot quicker.